Anyone interested in us selecting an all start team? If so, here's my suggestion of how it should work to keep it fair.
1. We need vote counters
2. 1 owner or representative from each team votes.
3. Owner/rep sends vote via PM to counter. This will allow people to be honest without worrying about ridicule or hurt feelings. And yes, no matter how small something is, people will get mad about something.
4. You can't vote for someone on your own team.
5. Owners can make one post here (edit instead of adding a lot more posts and making it cluttered) to nominate and make a case for players who they think deserve recognition even if the stats don't show it.
6. Vote for one person per starting position, including Kicker, Punter, Kick Returner and Punt Returner.
7. Vote for an Offensive MVP, Defensive MVP, Special Teams MVP and an Overall MVP.
8. Vote for people within your conference. So we'll have an Alpha All Star Team and Zeta All Star Team.
9. A counter from the Zeta Conference will calculate the Alpha team and a counter from the Alpha Conference will calculate the Zeta team to avoid any concerns about ethics.
10. One player per position is selected for the All Star Team unless there is a tie and both/all players are listed.
11. To vote list out the roster positions, and next to the position put the player's full name and team name. We have to make this easy on the counters and keep them from spending too much time on this. This will also help the counter make sure that no one voted for someone from their own team.
What do you think?
Edit 1: Modified Rule 2 to specify that its one person from each team
Edit 2: Added Rules 9-11
1. We need vote counters
2. 1 owner or representative from each team votes.
3. Owner/rep sends vote via PM to counter. This will allow people to be honest without worrying about ridicule or hurt feelings. And yes, no matter how small something is, people will get mad about something.
4. You can't vote for someone on your own team.
5. Owners can make one post here (edit instead of adding a lot more posts and making it cluttered) to nominate and make a case for players who they think deserve recognition even if the stats don't show it.
6. Vote for one person per starting position, including Kicker, Punter, Kick Returner and Punt Returner.
7. Vote for an Offensive MVP, Defensive MVP, Special Teams MVP and an Overall MVP.
8. Vote for people within your conference. So we'll have an Alpha All Star Team and Zeta All Star Team.
9. A counter from the Zeta Conference will calculate the Alpha team and a counter from the Alpha Conference will calculate the Zeta team to avoid any concerns about ethics.
10. One player per position is selected for the All Star Team unless there is a tie and both/all players are listed.
11. To vote list out the roster positions, and next to the position put the player's full name and team name. We have to make this easy on the counters and keep them from spending too much time on this. This will also help the counter make sure that no one voted for someone from their own team.
What do you think?
Edit 1: Modified Rule 2 to specify that its one person from each team
Edit 2: Added Rules 9-11
Last edited May 25, 2008 14:03:33