I say Sanders. What you guys think?
Dont bring up no one else name its just who is better between THIS TWO.
Dont bring up no one else name its just who is better between THIS TWO.
Last edited Apr 5, 2008 20:35:21
Forum > Free for All > Better RB Sanders or Campbell?
Whatsdafus
offline
offline
Payton did it all, run catch pass... not only juked people out of their jocks and shoes... but ran them over.
best all purpose back ever.
best all purpose back ever.
GeneralMakaveli
offline
offline
Originally posted by Whatsdafus
Payton did it all, run catch pass... not only juked people out of their jocks and shoes... but ran them over.
best all purpose back ever.
Again mite had done everything but not part of my question. Also All purpose yes best ever No. Second best ever Yes.
Payton did it all, run catch pass... not only juked people out of their jocks and shoes... but ran them over.
best all purpose back ever.
Again mite had done everything but not part of my question. Also All purpose yes best ever No. Second best ever Yes.
Legacy
offline
offline
Originally posted by Whatsdafus
Payton did it all, run catch pass... not only juked people out of their jocks and shoes... but ran them over.
best all purpose back ever.
I agree.
Makaveli, your avatar gives your bias away. To answer your question, I'd go with Campbell, but both were incredible backs. Sanders was unbelievably good at making people miss, but once you got him wrapped up, he was going down. Campbell could make people miss and had a way of slipping free even when 2 guys were all over him.
Payton did it all, run catch pass... not only juked people out of their jocks and shoes... but ran them over.
best all purpose back ever.
I agree.
Makaveli, your avatar gives your bias away. To answer your question, I'd go with Campbell, but both were incredible backs. Sanders was unbelievably good at making people miss, but once you got him wrapped up, he was going down. Campbell could make people miss and had a way of slipping free even when 2 guys were all over him.
GeneralMakaveli
offline
offline
Originally posted by Legacy
Originally posted by Whatsdafus
Payton did it all, run catch pass... not only juked people out of their jocks and shoes... but ran them over.
best all purpose back ever.
I agree.
Makaveli, your avatar gives your bias away. To answer your question, I'd go with Campbell, but both were incredible backs. Sanders was unbelievably good at making people miss, but once you got him wrapped up, he was going down. Campbell could make people miss and had a way of slipping free even when 2 guys were all over him.
There are many times sanders had more then one ppl trying to tackle him and he broke them. He was more in to just making them miss tho. Also Just because my avatar is Sanders is no point to be Bias. I just like Sanders the way he ran is in no comparison to any RB to play or to that has played since.
Originally posted by Whatsdafus
Payton did it all, run catch pass... not only juked people out of their jocks and shoes... but ran them over.
best all purpose back ever.
I agree.
Makaveli, your avatar gives your bias away. To answer your question, I'd go with Campbell, but both were incredible backs. Sanders was unbelievably good at making people miss, but once you got him wrapped up, he was going down. Campbell could make people miss and had a way of slipping free even when 2 guys were all over him.
There are many times sanders had more then one ppl trying to tackle him and he broke them. He was more in to just making them miss tho. Also Just because my avatar is Sanders is no point to be Bias. I just like Sanders the way he ran is in no comparison to any RB to play or to that has played since.
skippyjlo
offline
offline
I say Sanders. I wish the Lions would've released him, and let him show what he could've done behind a good offensive line.
Freakshow
offline
offline
Sanders is definately the most fun to watch BUT
Campbell is the most powerful back to run the ball.
I like them both...I do have a Earl Campbell rookie card though.
Campbell is the most powerful back to run the ball.
I like them both...I do have a Earl Campbell rookie card though.
BleedingBlackandOrange
offline
offline
Im gonna go with sanders... Campbell was amazing but everyone knew Sanders was gonna get the ball they stacked 8 in the box every play and he still shredded the Defense... Both were great to watch along with several other great RB... But sanders had no line and still did what he did... Absolutely amazing player...
GeneralMakaveli
offline
offline
Originally posted by BleedingBlackandOrange
Im gonna go with sanders... Campbell was amazing but everyone knew Sanders was gonna get the ball they stacked 8 in the box every play and he still shredded the Defense... Both were great to watch along with several other great RB... But sanders had no line and still did what he did... Absolutely amazing player...
Agree and you name is the longest ive even seen lol.
Im gonna go with sanders... Campbell was amazing but everyone knew Sanders was gonna get the ball they stacked 8 in the box every play and he still shredded the Defense... Both were great to watch along with several other great RB... But sanders had no line and still did what he did... Absolutely amazing player...
Agree and you name is the longest ive even seen lol.
Herdmaster
offline
offline
Apples and oranges. Sanders ran to avoid contact, Campbell invited it. I hate to compare players from different era's, but longevity has to play a factor here...neither played as long as they could have, but in my opinion, Barry was the better back.
Best of all time? No.
You gotta do everything to be the best...Barry didn't block and was only a slightly better than average receiver.
Best of all time? No.
You gotta do everything to be the best...Barry didn't block and was only a slightly better than average receiver.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.
