User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Announcements > GLBOA et al.
Page:
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Ok, with all the recent cheating/gutting stuff going on, this was brought to my attention and I think it's a great idea.

I know there's an unofficial GLB Owner's Association (and a Player's Association) that has been floating around the forum. I also know that some players would like the organization to be more involved.

My suggestion, and I would love some feedback on it, would be to officially recognize these groups and give them some power to decide what happens in the game.

The authority granted to the group could include:
- Levy fines against a particular team for cheating or doing something unethical
- Force reversal of an unfair trade
- Make decisions regarding contract disputes
- Etc.

All actions would have to go through an admin, but we'd probably just go with what the commission decides generally.

All team owners would have to accept the rules of the association, which would be presented in brief when buying a team.

I would think election of some sort of "commissioners" would be needed to keep the group organized. The commissioners could have some mod powers, etc, and they would get titles on the forum so you know who they are. We could even reward them for their service with FP if the job is demanding.

At first, I'm thinking this would just consist of a forum for dispute discussion, and decisions would have to be PMed to me or DD to take care of. What I envision, however, is eventually adding some tools for members to vote on propositions, submit actions, and review cases, assuming the association works out ok.

It seems that something like this would help the players of the game govern themselves in a pretty fair manner, as long as admins have the ultimate say to make sure there isn't something completely ridiculous decided on.

Thought and suggestions are welcome! We want to move forward and keep the wheels of progress turning.
Last edited Apr 6, 2008 00:58:15
 
Link
 
I believe it is a great idea.
 
Stobie
MoD
offline
Link
 
I agree! Implement the plan! Just no lockouts!!!
 
Freakshow
offline
Link
 
Awesome, I like the fact that a player driven union/group has some say (especially when there are some that don't play fair).
 
Babyfacer
offline
Link
 
Sounds pretty cool if managed right...

this wont turn into an All-Owner Union will it now, or will a "Player type Union" get it's own resprensetation as well?
Last edited Apr 5, 2008 20:42:11
 
Vyeth
offline
Link
 
Oustanding idea! A governement for the people and by the people.. Sounds like somewhere else I know..
 
zbuckley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vyeth
Oustanding idea! A governement for the people and by the people.. Sounds like somewhere else I know..


yes
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
I like the idea but my main concern/worry is power trips... there needs to be some clear cut regulations/rules/philosophies that the groups go by and these regulations/rules need to be laid out for everyone to see so a player or owner can not be blindsided with a rule that 3 or 4 people decide to just create out of thin air because they don't like something.
 
James42688
offline
Link
 
perfect...im glad these 2 are our mods
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bluemonick
Sounds pretty cool if managed right...

this wont turn into an All-Owner Union will it now, or will a "Player type Union" get it's own resprensetation as well?


I think that would be great to have as well. LOL, as long as there are no lockouts or collective bargaining agreements regarding merchandising rights.
 
NOVASaint
offline
Link
 
I'm on board with this idea.
 
Link
 
So you're saying you'd like the players to take some responsibility for the integrity of the game??

No, I'm totally against that
 
purehatred
offline
Link
 
I like the idea, although I think at some point you may need to find a "commissioner" or "board of directors": people who are willing to help mediate disputes who don't own a player or a team so they don't have ANY conflict of interests.

 
jprietman
offline
Link
 
I support the idea. I, too, am worried about power trips though. I don't think they should be able to reverse any transactions, but I think they should be able to debate over transactions, come to a decision, and then ask the admins to reverse it. The admins would then have the ultimate decision over whether something gets reversed. The only people I REALLY trust in this game are the ones who made it.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by purehatred
I like the idea, although I think at some point you may need to find a "commissioner" or "board of directors": people who are willing to help mediate disputes who don't own a player or a team so they don't have ANY conflict of interests.



That's why everything would have to go through the admins at some level - so we can weed out the decisions that are obviously biased.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.